Dec 2016
9:15pm, 1 Dec 2016
13,885 posts
|
Wriggling Snake
Embers was an excellent bowler. Mis-used. Edmonds for the disliked 11.
|
Dec 2016
10:14pm, 1 Dec 2016
4,633 posts
|
Ceratonia
Mike Brearley had some interesting comments on both of them as a captain - he reckons Edmonds was a much better bowler but Emburey worked hard on all aspects of his game and had a career to match.
|
Dec 2016
10:49pm, 1 Dec 2016
307 posts
|
Scorge
throwing this one out for the anoraks - the 'only got one test century and not much else XI'? mitch johnson springs to mind, along with any number of england openers. have fun!
|
Dec 2016
6:30am, 2 Dec 2016
87,804 posts
|
GregP
A 'one hit wonder' XI? Can I get Graham Napier into it on an exemption that he deserves a place somewhere?
|
Dec 2016
8:32am, 2 Dec 2016
13,889 posts
|
Wriggling Snake
Neil Mallender gets in that team, as does Norman Cowans, Devon Malcolm, Ballance, Robson, Lyth......
|
Dec 2016
8:39am, 2 Dec 2016
87,807 posts
|
GregP
Charlie Childs? Not sure what he did 'wrong' as an England player.
|
Dec 2016
8:52am, 2 Dec 2016
9,149 posts
|
Nicholls595
Napier hit it more than once. Only "that" one innings mind.
|
Dec 2016
9:09am, 2 Dec 2016
4,639 posts
|
Ceratonia
Bit harsh on Devon Malcolm. Obviously everyone remembers him for that game against SA, which is right up there with Headingley 1981 IMO, but he had a pretty long test career and plenty of wickets.
(Do we all know the story about the SA game? Malcolm destroyed them with figures of 9-57 on a pitch where England had been scoring at more than 5 an over, unheard of in test cricket in the 90s. When he phoned home, his wife said, "I've been out shopping all day, did you get any wickets dear?" and managed to keep the joke going for some time...)
|
Dec 2016
9:12am, 2 Dec 2016
87,808 posts
|
GregP
|
Dec 2016
9:18am, 2 Dec 2016
13,933 posts
|
Atonal Miserabilist (AFKA TRO)
I liked Devon Malcolm. He combined a sort of hapless ineptitude with occasional bursts of genuinely fearsome hostile fast bowling.
David 'Syd' Lawrence, another fave. Think his knee exploded while busting a gut bowling his heart out in some non test tour game?
|