Hi ,
It looks like you're using an ad blocker.



The revenue generated from the adverts on the site is a critical part of our funding - and it's because of these ads that I can offer the site for free. But using the site for free AND blocking the ads doesn't feel like a great thing to do, which is why this box is so large and inconvenient. Some sites will completely block your access, but I'm not doing that - I'm appealing to your good nature instead. Did you know that you can allow ads for specific sites, whilst still blocking them on others?

Thanks,
Ian Williams aka Fetch

F'Laps - Saturday 5th July

Join in with our challenge this Saturday. Run a set distance every hour until you can't run any more!
or for an ad-free Fetcheveryone experience!

The Immortalists - Book Group March 2020 discussion thread

8 watchers
Mar 2020
7:31am, 23 Mar 2020
34,431 posts
  • Quote
  • Pin
LindsD
So did I! :)
Mar 2020
9:05am, 23 Mar 2020
504 posts
  • Quote
  • Pin
Peregrinator
I gave it 8/10 - must develop a consistent scoring grid. I was keen to get back to reading it, to find out what happened, which has to be a recommendation. For me, the research and didactic are what made it an engaging read, even if ultimately I rejected what I took to be the underlying idea.

There's probably a whole area of study of families in literature. These four were so varied and I didn't get much feeling of why they would react so differently. Or what part the Jewish background played, which I thought the author could have worked in more.

Bit worried about using the phrase Deus ex Machina, but if there's flack, I'll hide behind McG.
Mar 2020
9:07am, 23 Mar 2020
34,439 posts
  • Quote
  • Pin
LindsD
In a way I agree, Pere. I didn't think the story needed Eddie Irishcop. He was too much of a coincidence.
Mar 2020
9:39am, 23 Mar 2020
16,756 posts
  • Quote
  • Pin
Serendippily
I would accept Simon is derivative, K (forgotten name already) unlikely and inconsistent, D dull and inconsistent, V unlikely. But relationships between them - Vera and Ruby, Ruby and Daniel, K and S - were enough. Bits of fathers and sons were stereotyped. Bits were unlikely. But there were some cracking powerful scenes in a short book and plenty to think on. And this was a good easy read. And I have room for both and glad of them both.
Mar 2020
9:40am, 23 Mar 2020
16,757 posts
  • Quote
  • Pin
Serendippily
But it’s still a good review :-)
Mar 2020
9:49am, 23 Mar 2020
34,444 posts
  • Quote
  • Pin
LindsD
I agree with all. And I'm so glad to have read it.
Mar 2020
10:54pm, 24 Mar 2020
507 posts
  • Quote
  • Pin
Peregrinator
Now feel I should reread some Armistead Maupin to see how it appears in a different world. How does one decide between revisiting and moving on? Maybe I could get Offspring1 to read and comment - he's about the age I was.
Mar 2020
10:55pm, 24 Mar 2020
34,499 posts
  • Quote
  • Pin
LindsD
I've been thinking similarly, but I really don't want to ruin it.
Mar 2020
11:02pm, 24 Mar 2020
46,572 posts
  • Quote
  • Pin
Diogenes
I read Maupin’s tales of the city series back in the early 90s. I felt a bit meh about them, but I might not have been best placed to appreciate the genre. It felt to me like the subject was more than the telling. It all felt a bit soap opera. Probably unfair.
Apr 2020
10:36am, 9 Apr 2020
19,584 posts
  • Quote
  • Pin
Columba
Finished last night, rather to my relief. It wasn't gripping me, and a number of things about it were annoying me.

The style: short, breathless sentences, frequent new paragraphs. True, this may have been only (or mainly) in the Simon and Klara sections, and intended to reflect their style of living.

The book seemed to be trying to do too many things at once. It's the story of a family. It's an exploration of the effect that "knowing" a future event may have on the way one chooses to live one's life. It's an account of a gay man's life at the time AIDS was just appearing over the horizon. It's the account of the life of someone with OCD. It touches on the cruelty involved in animal experimentation (reminding me of We Are All Completely Beside Ourselves).

And there were several instances - I can only think of one of them now - where the author airily describes an event which if you try to visualise it you realise is impossible. The one I remember is when someone (I think it's Daniel) is driving, and he's very upset, and he pulls over to the side of the road, and parks, and puts his head down on his knees - wait a moment, he does what? How can you put your head on your knees when you're sitting in the driver's seat?

Back to p 1 of this thread, to see what everyone else thought.

About This Thread

Maintained by McGoohan
Here's a house, here's a door. Windows: 1 2 3 4. Ready to knock? Turn the lock – It's Book Group!

Shall we see what window we're going to look through today?

Let's try the arched window. Ah, Brian Cant has got Big Ted in a headlock and he's screaming "Die! You furry bastard! Die!". Maybe not then.

Don't look through the round window, Jemima! It'll tell you the day you will die! No, don't do it Jemima. Too late.

Children, let's look through the square window instead. Oh look, it's Hamble and she's reading The Immortalists by Chloe Benjamin.
  • Show full description...

Related Threads

  • bookgroup
  • books

Report This Content

You can report any content you believe to be unsafe. Please let me know why you believe this content is unsafe by choosing a category below.



Thank you for your report. The content will be assessed as soon as possible.










Back To Top

Tag A User

To tag a user, start typing their name here:
X

Free training & racing tools for runners, cyclists, swimmers & walkers.

Fetcheveryone lets you analyse your training, find races, plot routes, chat in our forum, get advice, play games - and more! Nothing is behind a paywall, and it'll stay that way thanks to our awesome community!
Get Started
Click here to join 114,480 Fetchies!
Already a Fetchie? Sign in here